How Is a Private Loan Rate Set?

At Prima Finance, the rate on a private mortgage loan generally ranges from 12% to 24% per year. This rate is not a penalty: it reflects the risk the lender agrees to take when the bank says no.

The more security a file offers, the lower the risk, and the lower the rate. Here are the factors that make it vary, followed by three examples with real numbers so you can make a true comparison with a bank loan.

Why Do You Sometimes See Lower Rates Elsewhere?

When comparing, you may see advertised rates lower than ours. Often, these low ranges mainly correspond to B lenders’ rates: lenders that sit between the bank and private lending, and that still require a fairly solid credit file and income.

Private lending is for files that the bank and B lenders cannot accept: damaged credit, income that is hard to prove, a consumer proposal, late taxes or payments, a prior notice of exercise (commonly called the 60-day notice). These files are more complex and require a more in-depth review.

A private loan is also short-term, generally from 3 to 24 months. The review and setup costs are spread over a short period, which is reflected in the cost.

If your file qualifies with a B lender, that is often a better option: a mortgage broker can help you check. In all cases, compare the total cost (rate, fees and term) over the same period, and ask for it in writing.

The 6 Factors That Make the Rate Vary

1. How much of the house you really own (the loan-to-value ratio)

We compare what you owe on the house with what it is worth. For example, if your house is worth $400,000 and you owe $200,000, your debts represent 50% of its value. The more “free” money remains in the house, the more reassured the lender is, and the lower the rate can go. We lend up to 75% of the property’s value. Why 75%? For a refinance, a bank generally lends up to 80% of the value: on a $100,000 house, it lends $80,000, and the remaining $20,000 is its safety cushion. On a purchase, it can lend up to 95%, but only because the loan is insured, for example by CMHC. The client pays for this insurance, which is added to the loan, and it protects the bank. A private lender has no insurer behind it: the only safety cushion is the free money in the house. That is why it asks for a bigger cushion.

2. The rank of the mortgage

If the house has to be sold, the first-rank lender is repaid first, and the second-rank lender comes after. A second-rank loan is therefore riskier, and its rate is a little higher.

3. The location

In a big city, a house generally sells fairly quickly. The more remote it is, the longer it can take to sell if necessary, and the higher the risk for the lender. In small towns and villages, there are also fewer lenders: often only certain banks or credit unions, and few B lenders. So there are fewer choices to refinance and get out of the private loan. And if payments stop and the house has to be sold, interest keeps building up for the entire duration of the sale. The longer the sale, the more that interest eats into the equity, and the less money is left to repay the lender. The value of the house also matters: some fees are fixed, regardless of the price. For example, notary fees of $2,000 represent 2% of a $100,000 house, but only 0.4% of a $500,000 house. On a lower value, these fees weigh much more heavily. That is why, in general, properties under $250,000 are much riskier for a lender. They can still be financed when the risk is very low, for example when a lot of equity remains and the amount requested is small.

4. The condition of the property

A house in good condition, on a poured concrete foundation, and connected to the city’s water and sewer systems is easier to resell. It therefore reassures the lender more.

5. The exit plan

Before lending, we ask how the loan will be repaid: by a return to the bank or by a planned sale. The clearer and more realistic this plan, the lower the risk.

6. The amount and term of the loan

Our loans range from $50,000 to $400,000, for a term of 3 to 24 months, and sometimes longer depending on needs. Other strategies may also exist depending on your situation: feel free to discuss them with us.

Example 1: Compare the Payments, Not Just the Rates

The real gap is not between 5% and 12%. It is between about 7% and 12% of payments per year, because a bank payment also includes repaying the principal.

For $100,000 borrowed:

BankPrivate loan
Rate5%12%
Payment typeInterest + principal, over 25 yearsInterest only
Monthly payment$582$1,000
Payments per year, as a % of the loanabout 7%12%

In practical terms: at the bank, part of that 7% reduces your balance. With a private loan, the balance stays the same. That is why a private loan must remain temporary, while you get back on track.

“But my principal doesn’t go down?” That’s intentional. Over a short period, adding principal repayment to the interest would make the payment skyrocket: repaying $100,000 in 12 months at 12% would require more than $8,800 per month. The goal is for the loan to cost as little as possible, for the shortest possible period, so that you can get out of it as easily as possible.

Example for illustration purposes only. Assumptions: bank loan amortized over 25 years, interest compounded semi-annually; private loan interest only. Every application is subject to file review.

Example 2: With a Second Mortgage, Look at the Average Rate

With a second-rank loan, you don’t pay 16% on the whole amount. The average rate on all your loans is about 6.6%.

LoanAmountRateMonthly payment
First mortgage at the bank (25 years)$300,0005%$1,745
Second-rank private loan (interest only)$50,00016%$667
Total$350,000about 6.6% (weighted rate)$2,411

Calculating the weighted rate: ($15,000 + $8,000 of interest per year) ÷ $350,000 = 6.6%.

For comparison, a full refinance of $350,000 at 5% would mean a payment of about $2,036 per month. The difference is about $375 per month, and only for the duration of the private loan.

Example for illustration purposes only. Assumptions: bank loan amortized over 25 years, interest compounded semi-annually; private loan interest only. Every application is subject to file review.

Example 3: Secured Private Loan or Credit Cards?

Credit cards and many unsecured personal loans often cost 20% to 30% per year. With good security on the property, a private loan at 18% can cost much less.

For $50,000 of debt:

Credit cardsSecured private loan
Rate29%18%
Interest per year$14,500$9,000
Interest per monthabout $1,208$750

The difference is about $5,500 of interest per year. The file fee, at least $4,000, reduces this saving in the first year: it must be included in the calculation.

Caution: this refinancing only helps if the cards are not run up again afterward. Otherwise, you add debt to the house without solving the problem.

Example for illustration purposes only, simple interest on the balance. Every application is subject to file review.

Fees, in Full Transparency

No money is paid to Prima Finance before signing at the notary’s office. If an appraisal is required, its fees are paid directly to the certified appraiser. If anyone asks you for fees up front, be wary.

FeeAmountWhen it is paid
File fee2% to 5% of the loan amount, minimum $4,000At the notary’s office, at signing; it can be included in the loan
NotarySet by the notaryAt signing
Certified appraiser (only if needed)Set by the appraiserDirectly to the appraiser, at the time of the appraisal

A Private Loan Is a Temporary Solution

The goal of a private loan is most often to give you time to rebuild your credit file. We support you through this process. The exit, whether a return to the bank or a planned sale, is planned before signing, not after.

The shorter the loan, the less it costs. A 12% annual rate represents about 1% per month. If the loan lasts only 6 months, you pay about 6% of the amount borrowed in interest, not 12%. For example, for $100,000 borrowed for 6 months, the interest is about $6,000. The file fee is added to this amount: it must therefore be included when calculating the total cost.

For what comes next, also read: The Exit Plan: How You Get Out of a Private Loan

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the rate higher than at the bank?

Because the lender accepts a risk the bank refused. The rate reflects that risk: the more security the file offers, the lower it goes.

Why are some advertised rates lower than yours?

The low ranges advertised elsewhere often correspond to B lenders’ rates, which require a fairly solid credit file and income. Private lending is for more complex files, for a short term, which is reflected in the rate. Always compare the total cost, fees included, over the same period. Every application is subject to file review.

Will I sink even deeper?

It is a real risk if the loan has no exit plan. That is why we never lend without an exit planned from day one.

How do I get out of a private loan?

Most often by refinancing with the bank, once the credit file has been rebuilt, or by a planned sale. The plan is set with you before signing.

How do I recognize a trustworthy lender?

A trustworthy lender explains its rates and fees in writing, asks for no money before signing at the notary’s office and plans an exit with you.

Let’s Talk About Your Situation

Fill out our application form for a free, confidential, no-obligation consultation. We respond within 48 business hours.

Apply now

Prima Finance ltée, private mortgage financing company. 6000 boulevard de Rome, Suite 410, Brossard, Quebec J4Y 0B6. (438) 258-4353. Every application is subject to file review.

Back to top